Murray Franklin
Dick Kelly
Rudy
Ben
Billy 'The Kid' McDonnen
Patrick 'Paddy' Connors
Fred Blake / Giovanni Manzoni
Don Griffin
Pat Solatano Sr.
Stan Harris
Hunter
Carl Van Loon
Jack Byrnes
Senator John McLaughlin
Captain Shakespeare
Jack Byrnes
Don Lino (voice)
Self (archive footage) (uncredited)
Paul Vitti
Det. Mitch Preston
Nick Wells
Jack Byrnes
Master Chief Leslie W. Sunday ('Billy')
Fearless Leader
Paul Vitti
Sam
Conrad Brean
Lt. Moe Tilden
Louis Gara
Neil McCauley
James Conway
Al Capone
Jake LaMotta
Michael Vronsky
Travis Bickle
Vito Corleone